Pros and Cons of Credit Counseling Explained
- James Heinz
- 22 hours ago
- 9 min read
Introduction
When debt becomes overwhelming, many Americans seek a safe and structured way to get back on track. One option that often comes up is credit counseling, a service designed to provide financial education, repayment planning, and peace of mind. But is it always the right choice?
According to the National Foundation for Credit Counseling (NFCC), more than 1.2 million people in the U.S. seek help from credit counseling agencies each year, and about 70% of them enroll in debt management plans. While these programs can help some borrowers regain control, they aren’t a one-size-fits-all solution.
In this guide, we’ll break down the credit counseling pros and cons, explain how it compares to other debt relief options, and help you decide whether it’s the right step toward financial stability.
Key Takeaways
Credit counseling pairs you with a certified counselor to review your finances, build a budget, and (often) set up a Debt Management Plan (DMP) with one monthly payment.
Best for individuals with a steady income who can realistically repay balances in full over time and desire structure, education, and accountability.
You can pay in full with structure, want non-adversarial creditor cooperation, and need help with budgeting.
Balances are not repayable in full, collections are escalating, or you need faster relief (e.g., settlement or consolidation support).
Verify NFCC/FCAA accreditation, fee transparency, creditor relationships, reviews/complaints, and state licensing; avoid high-pressure sales.
What is Credit Counseling?
Credit counseling is a financial service that involves certified counselors working with individuals to understand their debt situation and create a practical repayment plan. The goal is to provide guidance, education, and structure.
A credit counseling session usually includes:
A review of your income, expenses, and outstanding debts.
Budgeting advice to help you manage day-to-day finances more effectively.
Discussion of repayment strategies, including the possibility of a Debt Management Plan (DMP).
A Debt Management Plan is one of the most common outcomes of credit counseling. Instead of juggling multiple bills, you make a single monthly payment to the counseling agency, which then distributes the funds to your creditors. This can sometimes include reduced interest rates or waived fees, making repayment more manageable.
It’s essential to note that credit counseling differs from debt settlement and debt consolidation. With counseling, you still repay your debts in full (often over several years), but with added support and structure to help you manage your finances effectively. Settlement and consolidation, on the other hand, work differently and may be more appropriate for those who cannot realistically repay the full balance.
Understanding the basics is only half the story. It’s just as important to know how the process works step by step.
How does Credit Counseling Work?
Credit counseling follows a structured process designed to give you clarity about your finances and a roadmap for repayment.
While the exact steps may vary depending on the agency, the process typically looks like this:
1. Initial Consultation
Most agencies begin with a free or low-cost consultation. During this session, a certified counselor reviews your income, expenses, and outstanding debts. The goal is to understand your full financial picture before recommending any solutions.
2. Budget and Financial Review
The counselor helps you create a realistic household budget that covers essential living expenses while freeing up money to pay down debt. This step also includes financial education, enabling you to better manage your spending habits and avoid falling back into debt later.
3. Discussion of Options
After assessing your situation, the counselor may recommend different paths, such as:
Continue to manage your debts effectively through improved budgeting.
Enrolling in a Debt Management Plan (DMP).
Considering other debt relief solutions if counseling isn’t the right fit.
4. Debt Management Plan (If Chosen)
If you enroll in a DMP:
You make one monthly payment to the counseling agency.
The agency distributes the funds to your creditors.
In some cases, creditors agree to reduced interest rates or waived fees, making the plan more manageable.
Most DMPs last three to five years, requiring steady income and discipline.
5. Ongoing Support
Throughout the process, counselors provide regular check-ins, resources, and guidance to help you stay on track. This can include tips for building savings, improving credit habits, and preparing for life after debt.
Once you see how credit counseling operates, it’s easier to weigh the benefits it can offer.
Pros of Credit Counseling
Credit counseling can be a lifeline for people who feel overwhelmed by debt but still can repay what they owe over time.
Here are some of the biggest advantages:
1. Expert Financial Guidance
Certified credit counselors offer personalized advice that extends beyond debt management. They help you create a budget, understand your spending habits, and develop better financial skills that last a lifetime.
2. Simplified Debt Repayment
Through a Debt Management Plan (DMP), multiple debts can be consolidated into a single, predictable monthly payment. This not only reduces the hassle of managing numerous due dates but also makes repayment more consistent and less stressful.
3. Potentially Lower Interest Rates and Fees
Counseling agencies often work directly with creditors to secure lower interest rates, waived late fees, or more affordable payment terms. While you still repay the principal balance, these concessions can save you money in the long run.
4. Reduced Stress and Added Accountability
Having a counselor on your side provides emotional relief. Debt is easier to manage when you’re not handling it alone. The structure of a DMP also adds accountability, helping you stick to your repayment goals.
5. Safe, Legal, and Regulated Option
Credit counseling is a legitimate and compliant method for debt relief. Unlike informal repayment negotiations, it’s conducted within legal and regulatory frameworks, giving you peace of mind that your plan is transparent and fair.
Of course, no solution is perfect. Along with these benefits, there are also some drawbacks to consider.
Cons of Credit Counseling
While credit counseling offers valuable structure and guidance, it isn’t the right solution for everyone. Before committing, it’s important to understand the limitations:
1. Long-Term Commitment
Debt Management Plans (DMPs) usually last three to five years. This requires a steady income and discipline to make every monthly payment on time. Missing payments can cause the plan to collapse.
2. Limited Debt Coverage
Credit counseling is most effective for unsecured debts, such as personal loans, medical bills, or certain lines of credit. It may not apply to all types of financial obligations, such as secured loans or business debts.
3. Fees May Apply
Although many agencies are nonprofit, credit counseling is rarely completely free. Please note that you may incur additional setup fees and monthly service charges, which will be factored into your overall costs.
4. Impact on Credit Access
Enrolling in a DMP can sometimes signal to lenders that you’re struggling financially. While it’s not as damaging as default or settlement, it may make it harder to qualify for new credit while in the program.
5. No Reduction of Principal
Unlike debt settlement, credit counseling does not lower the amount you owe. You’re still required to repay the full debt balance, just under potentially better terms.
Knowing the pros and cons is helpful, but the real question is whether credit counseling is the right choice for your specific situation.
When Should You Choose Credit Counseling?
`Credit counseling can be a helpful first step for people who feel overwhelmed by debt but still have the means to repay what they owe in full. The decision to choose this option depends largely on your financial situation, goals, and the level of flexibility you require.
Credit counseling is a good fit if -
You Have a Steady Income
Credit counseling works best when you have a reliable paycheck that allows you to make fixed monthly payments. Since most Debt Management Plans (DMPs) last three to five years, consistent income is essential to stay on track.
You Can Repay the Full Balance
If your debt is large but still manageable, and you want to repay what you owe without reducing the principal, credit counseling may be a strong option. The benefit lies in reduced interest rates and simplified payments, not debt forgiveness.
You Struggle With Budgeting
Many people fall deeper into debt because they lack a clear budget. Credit counseling provides financial education, helping you organize income and expenses so you don’t repeat the same mistakes.
You Want Structure Without Legal Risks
Unlike settlement or bankruptcy, credit counseling is a non-adversarial process. It allows you to work with creditors cooperatively, without the potential legal consequences of default.
You Feel Overwhelmed and Need Guidance
Sometimes, the biggest benefit of credit counseling is emotional. Having an expert on your side reduces stress and gives you confidence that you’re following a safe, compliant plan.
Credit counseling may not be enough in the following cases -
While credit counseling is a good option for many, it’s not designed for everyone. You may need to explore alternatives like debt settlement or consolidation if:
Your debt is too high to repay in full within a reasonable timeline.
You’re already behind on payments, and creditors are aggressively pursuing collections.
You want faster relief, and reducing the principal balance is the only realistic path forward.
If you’ve decided that counseling might be a good fit, the next step is to ensure you choose a reputable service.
Must Read: How Much of Your Income Should You Save? Finding the Right Balance for Your Financial Future
Tips to Choose the Best Credit Counseling Services
Not all credit counseling agencies are the same, and choosing the right one can make a big difference in your financial journey. Since you’ll be trusting them with sensitive financial details and possibly enrolling in a multi-year plan, it’s essential to carefully review the terms before signing up.
Here are key tips to guide you:
1. Look for Accreditation and Certification
Choose agencies that are accredited by recognized organizations such as the National Foundation for Credit Counseling (NFCC) or the Financial Counseling Association of America (FCAA). Certified counselors receive proper training and are required to adhere to strict ethical standards.
2. Understand the Costs Upfront
Even nonprofit agencies may charge setup fees or monthly maintenance fees for a Debt Management Plan (DMP). Reputable agencies will clearly disclose all costs in writing before you commit. Avoid services that pressure you into paying without transparency.
3. Ask About Services Beyond Debt Management
The best agencies provide budget counseling, financial education, and money-management workshops. These resources help you build long-term financial skills, not just short-term relief.
4. Verify Creditor Relationships
Agencies with established relationships with major lenders and creditors are more likely to negotiate interest rate reductions or fee waivers on your behalf. Ask about their track record and success rates.
5. Check Reviews and Complaints
Look at reviews from the Better Business Bureau (BBB) or your state’s consumer protection office. If an agency has a pattern of complaints or unresolved disputes, it’s a red flag.
6. Avoid High-Pressure Tactics
Reputable agencies will never rush you into making a decision. If a counselor insists you must “sign up today” or guarantees results that sound too good to be true, consider it a warning sign.
7. Confirm State Licensing
Some states require credit counseling agencies to be licensed. Make sure the agency you’re considering meets your state’s regulatory requirements.
Even with the best counseling service, you may find that repayment in full isn’t realistic. That’s where Shepherd Outsourcing comes in with broader solutions.
How Can Shepherd Outsourcing Help?
At Shepherd Outsourcing, we understand that debt doesn’t always follow the plan. Even with the best intentions, challenges like medical bills, job loss, or rising interest rates can make repayment difficult. Credit counseling can be a good starting point for some individuals, but it is not always sufficient. That’s where we step in.
Here’s how we support you beyond traditional credit counseling:
Customized Debt Solutions: We carefully assess your financial situation and design a tailored plan that meets your unique needs, whether that involves settlement, consolidation, or structured repayment.
Creditor Negotiation: Our experienced team negotiates directly with lenders to reduce your outstanding debt and secure lower interest rates, providing you with genuine relief.
Consolidation Support: If juggling multiple loans feels overwhelming, we help you combine them into one manageable payment, making repayment less stressful.
Legal & Compliance Protection: Every step is handled within strict legal and regulatory guidelines, so you are safeguarded against aggressive collections or lawsuits.
Ongoing Guidance: From your first consultation to the day you’re debt-free, we provide continuous support and financial counseling to keep you moving forward with confidence.
Conclusion
Credit counseling has its pros and cons. It works well if you can repay your full balance with structure and guidance, but it may fall short if your debt feels unmanageable. The good news is that you don’t have to figure it out on your own.
Shepherd Outsourcing is here to provide the expertise, negotiation power, and tailored strategies you need to take back control of your finances. Whether you’re weighing credit counseling or exploring alternatives, we can help you find the path that truly fits your situation.
Ready to take the next step? Contact Shepherd Outsourcing today and begin your path to financial freedom.
FAQs
1. Is credit counseling the same as debt settlement?
No. Credit counseling helps you repay your debts in full under a structured plan, while debt settlement involves negotiating with creditors to reduce the total balance owed.
2. Will credit counseling hurt my credit score?
Enrolling in a Debt Management Plan (DMP) does not directly damage your credit score. However, some lenders may view it as a sign of financial difficulty, which can make it harder to open new credit while on the plan.
3. How long does a Debt Management Plan usually last?
Most DMPs run for three to five years. Success depends on making every monthly payment on time until all debts are repaid.
4. Are credit counseling services free?
Not always. Even nonprofit agencies may charge setup fees and monthly maintenance fees. Be sure to ask about costs upfront.
5. What types of debt can credit counseling help with?
It typically works best for unsecured debts, such as medical bills, personal loans, or certain lines of credit. It may not apply to secured loans or business-related debts.
6. Who regulates credit counseling agencies?
Organizations like the NFCC or FCAA may accredit agencies, and some states also require licensing. Always check credentials before enrolling.
Comments